Two Different Versions on Why Khalid Ibrahim Was Fired from PKR

Yesterday, the Cardock Facebook account took a trip down memory lane, revisiting the political history of the Parti Keadilan Rakyat (PKR) during its heyday in Selangor.

The post stated that the 2014 sacking of the late Tan Sri Abdul Khalid Ibrahim from PKR presented two contrasting narratives: his personal claims and the party's official explanation.

According to Khalid Ibrahim's claims during his political talks, the primary reason for his dismissal was his refusal to allow Selangor state government funds to be used to finance PKR activities. He asserted that state administrative funds are public money that should not be misused for partisan political interests.

Conversely, PKR provided a different official reason for the disciplinary action. The PKR disciplinary board terminated him immediately for defying the party's decision requesting him to step down as Menteri Besar (Chief Minister) to facilitate the "Kajang Move".

Additionally, the party stated that the sacking stemmed from his failure to manage party welfare and several state administrative issues, including the Kinrara-Damansara Expressway (KIDEX) project controversy and the restructuring negotiations of the Selangor water industry.

In the comments section, a netizen named Jemang Misdan said: "Between the late Tan Sri Khalid's reasons and PKR's, I believe TS Khalid more. He promised free water, and he delivered. He promised educational aid for Selangor children, and he delivered. He did such a great job that the late Sultan of Selangor praised him as the best MB Selangor has ever had. In his entire life, he never had any corruption or moral scandals."

Another netizen, Suhaini binti Saperan, commented: "When the late MB was leading Selangor, I got to enjoy paying less than RM10 for water for years. Now, the monthly water bill is over RM40, even though our household is smaller because some of the kids are married and in college. ☺️ That's just how it is."

Only God knows the truth (Wallahualam).

End©Permadu

Visit Permadu Malaysia blog at permadumalaysia.blogspot.com


By Fauzi Kadir
Chief Editor

Assistant Editor
Jamaliah Mohd Salleh


Final editing and brought to you by
Fauzi Kadir CHIEF EDITOR

© 2026 Permadu Malaysia
(Semua Hak Cipta Terpelihara)
All Rights Reserved 
Contact us at permadu@gmail.com

(DILULUSKAN UNTUK SIARAN OLEH LEMBAGA SIDANG PENGARANG) 
PUBLISHED UPON APPROVAL BY THE EDITORIAL BOARD
Official and authorised bank account for Permadu Malaysia
Fauzi Bin Abd... 7600650948 CIMB Bank

Visiting Permadu Malaysia is absolutely free and we operate with non-profit making objective. We hope you enjoy and feel happy visiting and reading every presentation from us.

If you have the generosity to support our operations and continuous activities of charity to those who are less fortunate, we would be grateful to accept sincere contributions from any individuals or organisations. 

Contact us at permadu@gmail.com for further details and information. No obligation and no commitment.

Comments

Post a Comment

POPULAR POSTS from Permadu Malaysia

MAHATHIR MAY REJOIN UMNO

Image
What Mahathir expected did not happen Initially, Mahathir Mohamad thought his party – PPBM (Bersatu) – could  morph  into a new version of UMNO. After all, it was him who brilliantly destroyed the original UMNO in 1988 and created “UMNO Baru” (the current UMNO version 2.0). But unlike in 1988, Mr. Mahathir had quit UMNO to form PPBM on 8 September 2016, and was no longer in charge of UMNO. UMNO won four times higher than Bersatu in GE14 Hence, after he leveraged on opposition Pakatan Harapan and stunningly defeated the scandal-plagued Najib government, his first priority was  recruiting  UMNO MPs to join his party. UMNO, although lost miserably, still won 54 parliamentary seats in the May 2018 General Election – more than 4 times the number of seats Mahathir’s party managed to capture. PPBM the worst among four strategic parties Mahathir’s party won  only 13 seats  out of the 52 Parliamentary seats it contested in the 2018 poll. That’s ...
Read more

Ketua Pemuda UMNO ajak Ahli MKT UMNO bertumbuk

Image
Dua tokoh parti politik yang sukar dipisahkan dari imej rasuah , semakin panas bertelagah Rentak Madani 🎵 Akhbar Sinar Harian melaporkan semalam bahawa Ketua Pemuda UMNO, Datuk Dr Muhamad Akmal Saleh mencabar Ahli Majlis Kerja Tertinggi (MKT) UMNO,  Datuk Lokman Noor Adam  supaya berdepan dengannya sama ada di mahkamah ataupun di gelanggang, berikutan tuduhan kononnya beliau mempunyai agenda tersembunyi untuk menaikkan  Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein  sebagai Perdana Menteri. Amaran itu dibuat selepas Lokman secara terbuka menggelar beliau sebagai ‘Ketua Pemuda H20’ dalam satu wawancara bersama sebuah platform baru-baru ini. Menurut Muhamad Akmal, Lokman kini mempunyai dua pilihan, sama ada menjawab saman beliau di mahkamah ataupun bertemu di gelanggang bagi menyelesaikan isu berkenaan. “Kamu ada dua pilihan. Pilihan pertama, kita lawan di mahkamah. Aku saman kamu," cabar Akmal. Lokman berpendapat, Ahli Dewan Undangan Negeri (ADUN) Merlimau itu menggunakan kelebih...
Read more

Di sebalik misteri kehilangan Anita Sarawak

Image
  Kehilangan Anita terus jadi misteri Hanya andaian tanpa dapat disahkan kebenarannya Sekadar mengimbas rekod perkahwinan Anita Sarawak TAK boleh dinafikan, bahawa setiap orang menginginkan pernikahan hanya terjadi sekali dalam seumur hidupnya. Tapi inilah hidup, kita tidak boleh menjamin, tidak pula boleh menentukannya. Kerana semua ini sudah diatur oleh Yang Maha Kuasa. Penyanyi legenda yang sudah lama menghilang dari radar hiburan, pemilik nama sebenar Ithnaini binti Mohamed Taib atau lebih dikenali sebagai Anita  Sarawak  sudah ditakdirkan untuk beberapa kali bernikah sampai akhirnya benar-benar bertemu dengan jodoh yang sudah ditakdirkan untuknya. Ya, jodoh memang selalu tak diketahui manusia. Rindu akan senyuman dan aksi lincahnya di pentas, kami mahu kongsikan kisah suka duka Anita dalam percintaan dan penikahan sepanjang dalam hidupnya. Mohamed Abdul Samad Kali pertama Anita berkahwin ialah dengan pemuzik dari Singapura,  Mohamed Abdul Samad  pada ...
Read more

Isu Stadium Shah Alam, suami Hannah Yeoh dapat kontrak, parkir, terkini babi — faktor penyumbang PH kalah di PRN akan datang

Image
Lebih kurang UMNO juga Satu demi satu isu mencurigakan berlaku di Selangor. Pada mulanya Pakatan Harapan (PH) disangka akan membuat pembaharuan. Rupanya lebih kurang UMNO juga. Jika UMNO sudah dihukum rakyat di Selangor, maka sudah tiba giliran PH pula. Seperti tajuk di atas, isu Stadium Shah Alam, suami Menteri DAP Puan Hannah Yeoh dapat kontrak, kontroversi pemilik syarikat parkir, dan terkini kontroversi ladang babi dijangka akan menjadi faktor penyumbang PH kalah di PRN akan datang. Semalam,  MalaysiaGazette melaporkan b ekas Ketua Penerangan UMNO Selangor Encik Isham Jalil menyarankan Menteri Besar Selangor, para Exco Kerajaan Negeri dan penyokongnya supaya berpindah ke Bukit Tagar, kawasan berdekatan ladang babi yang menimbulkan kontroversi. Dengan tindakan berkenaan, barulah kepimpinan Selangor akan memahami bantahan  penduduk  Selangor terhadap cadangan untuk menjadikan negeri berkenaan sebagai pengeksport babi terbesar ke Singapura. “ Selepas   itu   b...
Read more

OVERCONCENTRATION OF A MALAY POPULATION MAKES SHAH ALAM A GHOST CITY, SAYS ANALYST

Image
Shah Alam City YESTERDAY, FMT reported that the capital city of Selangor had become very quiet, slow and almost no business, many buildings unoccupied, which one of them only utilised by less than ten staff of a company. Some factories closed down, businesses from petty traders to big timers closed shops for the past six months and so on. Even foreign business people from Indonesia and Pakistan decided to go back to their respective countries or moved to other places. A prominent business analyst, in his blog wrote that one of the reasons for the downfall of Shah Alam was the government's policy in overconcentrating a Malay population in the said city. Syed Albar Ali also suggested other reasons as well. Below is the write-up as published by OutSyed The Box on 30 January 2020. Syed Akbar Ali's comments :   Just the other day Forest City announced 400 staff were being let go.  Could it be because things are not so great anymore? D...
Read more

Janganlah jealous lelaki Rohingya dapat awek Melayu cun💝

Image
Kalau kita nak tackle perempuan Melayu tetapi cinta kita ditolak, maka kita harus menghadapi kenyataan ini dengan tenang dan penuh istiqamah, pasrah lagi bertawakkal. Terimalah ia sebagai ketentuan Allah. Mungkin ada hikmah di sebaliknya. Perempuan itu memilih lelaki Rohingya atas penilaiannya sendiri. Mungkin dia terpikat dari aspek kegagahan, ketulusan cinta, keromantikan, kekacakan dan ke-handsome-an yang luar biasa keistimewaannya serta berbagai ciri-ciri lain yang tiada pada lelaki Melayu. Janganlah kita mengutuk takdir yang menentukan. Ia tidak akan merubah hati perempuan itu yang telah terkunci di dalam hati seorang jejaka Rohingya. Lagipun, sedarilah. Angkara pihak berkuasa yang mengelirukan, kita orang Melayu sudah menjadi warga kelas tiga yang menumpang dalam negara sendiri. Standard kita setakat menjadi penerima bantuan kerajaan sahaja. Semua orang luar seolah-olah bebas memasuki negara ini. Kita bukan siapa-siapa. Dalam satu hantaran penuh emosi semalam, akaun Facebook Fri...
Read more

Syukri Razab Presiden Parti Bersama Malaysia

Image
Dalam satu perkembangan yang agak memeranjatkan, teraju utama Parti Bersama Malaysia (Bersama) Datuk Seri Rafizi Ramli mengesahkan Encik Syukri Razab ( gambar , atas sekali ) adalah presiden parti itu dan namanya berdaftar dengan Pendaftar Pertubuhan (RoS - Registrar of Society) Malaysia. Beliau merupakan bekas pegawai khas kepada Rafizi Ramli. Selepas pengambilalihan parti tersebut, Rafizi dan Encik Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad mengambil alih peranan sebagai peneraju utama parti, namun Syukri Razab kekal memegang jawatan Presiden Parti Bersama. Rafizi menjelaskan sedikit sebanyak mengenai latar belakang Syukri dalam satu persembahan video hari ini. End © Permadu Kunjungi blog Permadu Malaysia di permadumalaysia.blogspot.com Oleh Fauzi Kadir Ketua Pengarang Penolong Pengarang Nazura Othman Suntingan terakhir dan dibawa kepada anda oleh Fauzi Kadir KETUA PENGARANG © 2026 Permadu Malaysia Semua Hak Cipta Terpelihara E-mel: permadu@gmail.com DILULUSKAN UNTUK SIARAN OLEH LEMBAGA SIDANG PENGARANG ...
Read more

LOKMAN TELLS AG: CHARGE MEN IN SEX VIDEO OR FACE OUR LAWSUIT

Image
POLITICIANS IN MALAYSIA Latest development on alleged Azmin's sex video Lokman Noor Adam speaking to reporters before entering federal police headquarters on Tuesday 3 September 2019 UMNO Supreme Council member Lokman Noor Adam issued an ultimatum to Attorney-General Tommy Thomas yesterday, Tuesday 3 September 2019, demanding the government charge the two men caught on video with unnatural sex or be taken to court for failure to prosecute, reported  Malay Mail . Tommy Thomas, Attorney General Lokman insisted he has irrefutable proof Lokman, who was called to Bukit Aman for questioning on the sex allegations insisted that he has irrefutable proof for action to be taken against Economic Affairs Minister Mohamed Azmin Ali and former Santubong PKR Youth chief Haziq Abdullah Abdul Aziz - said to be the two men in the sex video. "With the evidence we obtained from the UK-based firm, I hope the police can submit the investigation paper to AG to charge Azmin ...
Read more

Bersama expected to win half of PKR, DAP and Amanah's existing parliamentary and state seats in Johor

Image
Analysts say Johor state elections will be PH Vs BN — but they overlook Bersama PAS and Bersatu are expected to face a rough ride in the upcoming Johor state election, as both parties look set to go their own way while their potential allies appear lacklustre. Though both parties have announced efforts to form new political configurations amid Perikatan Nasional’s ongoing crisis, news portal FMT spoke to Dr Mazlan Ali of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia and he said these new alliances would not be earth-shattering in Johor. Mazlan said both parties had limited options for allies, having been linked to the same entities such as Berjasa, Pejuang, Putra, and Muda. He added that these small parties command little influence and are incapable of taking on Barisan Nasional or Pakatan Harapan. “I don’t see any real competition in Johor. It will be more like BN against PH, as PAS and Bersatu have been weakened by their division. “Although these small parties will want to help them, they will not ...
Read more

It happens everywhere—Not only in our country

Image
THE WOLF NEVER WANTED THE ARGUMENT A Wolf And A Lamb Meet At A Stream. Not As Enemies. As Neighbors Sharing Water. The Wolf Is Higher Up The Brook. The Water Runs From Him To Her. Still, He Accuses. “You Muddy My Water.” The Lamb Answers Gently. She Is Correct. Physics Is On Her Side. The Water Cannot Flow Upward. The Accusation Collapses Instantly. So The Wolf Replaces It. “I Heard You Spoke Ill Of Me Last Year.” The Lamb Explains Again. She Is Six Months Old. She Did Not Exist Last Year. Another Charge Fails. So The Wolf Stops Pretending To Care About Truth. “If It Was Not You, It Was Your Father.” And With That, The Argument Ends. The Teeth Appear. The Lamb Is Eaten. This Story Is Not About Cruelty. It Is About Power. The Wolf Never Wanted An Explanation. He Wanted A Justification. Each Accusation Was Not A Question But A Stepping Stone Toward An Outcome Already Decided. This Is The Pattern Predators Follow: They Accuse First. Then Adjust The Accusation Until Resistance Looks Like G...
Read more