Rafizi and Hamzah—Same but Different
Based on conversations with a political analyst, an academician and a politician, FMT reported yesterday the former ministers Datuk Seri Mohd Rafizi Ramli and Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin may share similar “battle scars”, yet they are engaged in parallel pursuits, on opposite ends of Malaysia’s crowded political spectrum.
Both men once held the influential deputy president’s post in their respective parties – Rafizi in PKR, Hamzah in Bersatu – before striking out on their own.
Rafizi, together with former PKR vice-president Encik Nik Nazmi Nik Ahmad, has taken over the reins of Parti Bersama Malaysia, positioning it as a fresh alternative in the reformist camp.
Hamzah, meanwhile, has unveiled his “Reset” movement, a banner under which he hopes to reshape the conservative bloc and rally disenchanted voters.
Encik Hisommudin Bakar of Ilham Centre said both men remain significant players in the political arena, describing them as influential “political operators”.
“The most obvious similarity is that they served as deputy presidents in their respective parties, a post that is not just symbolic in nature. They were part of an elite group that determined the party’s direction,” he said.
Both later become openly critical of their party leader and are now trying to build legitimacy for their new political movements, he said.
Hamzah was sacked from Bersatu in February, while Rafizi quit PKR in May.
But Hisommudin said the similarities largely stop there.
Hamzah, he said, is taking the more traditional political approach, built around party networks, grassroots structures and behind-the-scenes negotiations. Rafizi, on the other hand, is focused on digital campaigning and issue-based politics.
Rafizi, he said, understands that modern politics no longer relies solely on ceramahs and party meetings.
“He builds influence through podcasts, social media, and consistently structured political narratives aimed at attracting younger and anti-establishment voters.”
Hisommudin was commenting on comparisons made by social media users between Rafizi and Hamzah.
Prof Madya Dr Mazlan Ali of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia said Rafizi’s politics was more focused on reformist ideals linked to governance, transparency and civil society activism.
“Rafizi’s politics focuses on data and civil society movements such as Bersih, as well as issues such as transparency,” he said when contacted.
Mazlan said Rafizi was looking to woo urban youths, fence-sitters and non-Malay voters who were more interested in issues rather than party loyalty.
“They (the voters in these groups) look at issues such as the economy, job opportunities, AI, IT and the future,” he added.
However, Mazlan said Rafizi faces structural challenges, pointing out that any new solo movement would have to survive within Malaysia’s coalition-driven political environment.
He said Hamzah’s opportunity lies in positioning himself as PAS’s strategic partner, especially as more Bersatu grassroots leaders and division chiefs appear to be shifting their support towards him.
Former PKR vice-president Encik Tian Chua said Rafizi faces competition from an already crowded reformist party arena that includes PKR, DAP and Warisan.
On Hamzah, Tian Chua said his biggest challenge was not visibility but survival within an increasingly crowded Malay political ecosystem where PAS had emerged as the dominant force.
“When you already have three Malay-dominant parties competing within the same political space as Perikatan Nasional, the question becomes how seats and influence are distributed,” he said.
He added that while former home minister Hamzah’s organisational and support structures may currently appear stronger than Rafizi’s, he is nonetheless operating in an arena increasingly shaped and dominated by PAS.
“Rafizi is a strong orator and very good at attracting attention. But elections are ultimately based on good structure and grassroots machinery,” the former Batu MP said.
End©Permadu
Visit Permadu Malaysia blog at permadumalaysia.blogspot.com
| By Fauzi Kadir Chief Editor
|
Final editing and brought to you by |
1Visiting Permadu Malaysia is absolutely free and we operate with non-profit making objective. We hope you enjoy and feel happy visiting and reading every presentation from us.
If you have the generosity to support our operations and continuous activities of charity to those who are less fortunate, we would be grateful to accept sincere contributions from any individuals or organisations.
Contact us at permadu@gmail.com for further details and information. No obligation and no commitment.
Comments
Post a Comment