They look like Islam, but not Islam?

Prominent blogger Tuan Syed Akbar Ali expresses his opinion about Shariah laws in the country

He says..

Ke Bawah DYMM Raja-Raja Melayu: The Big Problem is There Is No Such Thing As A Fully Agreed And Fully Written Down Set Of Syariah Laws Anywhere In Islamic History 

Syed Akbar, via his blog OutSyed The Box (the blog with more than 100 million page views), was referring to the following news:

Religious minister suggested shariah enforcement dept in all states 

Empowered to act independently, conduct investigations, make arrests

He said currently enforcement section and not department

However only consider after states establish separate shariah prosecution dept

“Currently enforcement under Islamic religious department

We want all states establish shariah prosecution department first

For example Jawi shariah prosecution division now shariah prosecution dept

To ensure can act independently need to make it a department

Shariah judiciary committee to be formed

Conference of Rulers consented to national shariah judiciary committee 

To study and continuously monitor issues that arise in shariah courts

Syed Akbar Ali's Comments

The matter raised by Puan Nik Elin has nothing to do with the detailed definitions of what exactly is Syariah law.

The real story

Her contention, which has been agreed upon by the Federal Court, is that there should not be a duplication of jurisdiction between the Federal Court and the State Syariah Court of Kelantan over the same offences and their punishments. 

Nik Elin's actions have also established the Law of the land that the Federal Court is the highest court of the country. There are no other Courts that are equal to or superior to the Federal Court. 

We owe it to the genius of the British (or their regard and respect for the sovereignty of the Raja-Raja Melayu when the Federation of Malaya Agreement was signed in 1948) that religion was placed under the jurisdiction of the Raja-Raja Melayu. 

DYMM Tuanku Sultan Perak (my Sultan) signing the Federation of Malaya Agreement in January 1948. Daulat Tuanku.

Sincerely...

My sincere advise to the DYMM Raja-Raja Melayu is never, ever to cede their sovereignty over religious affairs to anyone else, and not especially to the politicians.

May I humbly suggest to the DYMM Malay Rulers that they must lead Malay public opinion to request a ban on religion from the political sphere completely. Giving the politicians even some say over religion is what has destroyed religion.

For example in Iran, the Ayatollahs have killed Islam. Over 50,000 masjid in Iran are permanently closed because the people are fed up with religion. This is what will happen if you give those who cannot use rational thinking and logic to manage the affairs of the state. It has continuously led to disaster.

There is no such thing as a fully agreed upon or a fully written down set of Syariah Laws at any time throughout 1,400 years of Islamic history.  In Malaysia the State syariah enactments differ between one State to the next.

Religion is best kept safely in the hearts of the believers. Religion is a matter of faith. Faith is a matter of the heart. 

Islam is an invitation, a persuasion. The Quran says so.

Surah 16:125  Invite to the way of your Lord with wisdom and good instruction, and argue with them in a way that is best. Indeed, your Lord is most knowing of who has strayed from His way, and He is most knowing of who is [rightly] guided Islam must be made free of rules, legislation and legislators. 

Islam is the only 'persuasion' in the world that DOES NOT recognise an official clergy. There is no such thing as the office of a pope, an ayatollah, an imam, a mufti, or a kadi in Islam.

It is the artificial creation of such positions which has created so much confusion among Muslims. 


Adapted from the article written by Tuan Syed Akbar Ali, published in his blog, OutSyed The Box, on Sunday, February 18, 2024.

The appearance and act on the above video are for illustration purpose only.

End©Permadu


Adaptation by Fauzi Kadir
Chief Editor

Assistant Editor
Nazura Othman


Final editing and brought to you by
Fauzi Kadir CHIEF EDITOR

© 2023 Permadu Harmony Bersepadu
(Semua Hak Cipta Terpelihara)
All Rights Reserved 
E-mail: permadu@gmail.com

(DILULUSKAN UNTUK SIARAN OLEH LEMBAGA SIDANG PENGARANG) 
PUBLISHED UPON APPROVAL BY THE EDITORIAL BOARD  

Comments

  1. MK.loansTue Feb 20, 03:28:00 PM 2024

    Kami adalah syarikat pinjaman yang boleh dipercayai, Kadar faedah yang dikenakan 2% anda boleh mendapatkan pinjaman daripada kami dengan mudah.

    Jenis pinjaman termasuk:

    Penyatuan hutang
    Pembaikan rumah
    Pembelian rumah utama
    Perbelanjaan perubatan
    pinjaman peribadi
    Pinjaman perniagaan

    Jika berminat untuk mendapatkan pinjaman daripada syarikat kami, hubungi kami terus melalui: mk.loans@yahoo.com

    Salam saya.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

POPULAR POSTS from Permadu Malaysia

Beer, khalwat and a hundred other non-halal things

Image
In one undated video clip, it was recorded that PAS president, Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang as clarifying that offences of corruption are not included in Hudud law. Watch Video "Corruption is not part of stealing", so it's hudud-free  Don't get confused with Hadi's version of Islamic understanding, we could have misinterpreted his explanation   Some people say Malays are not very particular about corruption, but... " Malays are particular about beer, khalwat and a hundred other non-halal things. They should use their self-discipline to avoid the non-halal stuff, but instead, they want the government to do it for them. So, the government willingly obliges; it makes laws that make it criminal for any sin, for their in moral lapses ," said Datuk Zaid Ibrahim. Expensive to enforce moral offences Expressing his personal views on Islamic moral offences, Zaid said: " This means you need spies to peep through doors; enforcement officers; the courts; and other g
Read more

Representing 22,000 lawyers, Malaysian Bar to challenge Pardons Board's reduced Najib's jail sentence and fine

Image
Media reported the Malaysian Bar has filed for judicial review to challenge the decision of the Federal Territories Pardons Board (FTPB) to halve former prime minister Datuk Seri Mohd Najib Tun Abdul Razak’s jail sentence and reduce the fine in his SRC International corruption conviction. In the application filed by solicitors Messrs Amir & Rajpal Ghat in the High Court last Friday, the Bar, which represents 22,000 lawyers practising in Peninsular Malaysia, sought a declaration that the board’s collective decision was unlawful, unconstitutional and void, according to FMT . It also requested an order of certiorari against the board to quash the FTPB’s decision. The board and Najib are named as respondents to the application. The Bar also wants a permanent injunction restraining Najib or his agents from submitting any application for pardon, reprieve or respite to the board until all criminal charges against him have been exhausted. The Bar said the injunction should remain in force
Read more

Handsome anak lelaki tunggal Anwar Ibrahim dan Wan Azizah

Image
  Ke-handsome-an Mohd Ihsan melayakkannya menjadi artis selebriti macam Dafi, anak PM Ismail Sabri Mohd Ihsan Anwar Ibrahim Sepasang suami isteri yang sentiasa matang dan sejahtera Siapa tak kenal ahli parlimen Permatang Pauh Anak-anak perempuan pun apa kurangnya.. cantik, manis dan menarik Nurul Nuha Anwar Ibrahim Nurul Ilham Anwar Ibrahim Nurul Iman Anwar Ibrahim Nurul Hana Anwar Ibrahim Rakyat Malaysia tumpang gembira Gambar-gambar dari hantaran Princess Nur Jannah di akaun Facebook Dr Wan Azizah Wan Ismail hari ini. End © Permadu Disediakan oleh Jamaliah Mohd Salleh Penulis Berita Permadu Malaysia Dibawa kepada anda oleh Ketua Pengarang © 2021 P ermadu Harmony Bersepadu Semua Hak Cipta Terpelihara E-mail  permadu@gmail.com Permadu DILULUSKAN OLEH JEMAAH SIDANG PENGARANG
Read more

Singapura Tanam Padi

Image
"Siapa bilang perempuan Melayu tak cantik kan" Gambar terkini Mazianna Abdul Aziz, kawan sekolah rendah Permadu di Temerloh, berpuluh tahun yang lalu. Menghiasi slot Cover Page untuk artikel kali ini. Seperti sering disarankan oleh pemilik dan penulis blog terkenal Syed Akbar Ali, seseorang harus berfikir di luar kotak untuk mencapai kejayaan. Bersesuaian dengan nama blog itu, OutSyed The Box. Ahli Fikir Dari Permatang Pauh telah mengirimkan rakaman video untuk dikongsi bersama, berkaitan aktiviti eksperimental penanaman padi di sebuah republik bersaiz kecil di atas pulau. Selamat menonton: Yang di bawah ini pula, Permadu merasa teringin untuk makan bersama-sama. Wahh, sedapnya... kalau nak kari sedap, semestinya kari India. Sudikah kiranya... Terima kasih kerana mengunjungi Permadu Malaysia.  End © Permadu Oleh Fauzi Kadir, Ketua Pengarang Dibantu oleh Kwai Fong Chin,  Penolong Pengarang Suntingan terakhir dan dibawa kepada anda oleh Fauzi Kadir   KETUA PENGARANG © 2023 Perm
Read more

Kuasa didahulukan, reformasi dikemudiankan – realiti yang akan dilakukan semua perdana menteri

Image
Bergabung dengan BN  yang punya banyak rekod buruk sebab utama PH tak dapat laksana reformasi Dalam politik, kita sebagai rakyat biasa selalunya sukar untuk lari dari kekeliruan. Kekeliruan yang hadir dari beraneka kenyataan dan pandangan dari orang-orang politik. Amat susah untuk mempercayai kenyataan-kenyataan orang politik adalah ikhlas dan tidak bermotifkan politik.  Penyudahnya, semua pandangan dan kenyataan daripada semua pihak yang bertentangan, dimasukkan ke dalam kawah kari, digaul di atas api, maka terjumpalah sehelai seluar dalam yang sudah dipakai dan tidak dibasuh, khabarnya untuk dijadikan pelaris , di dalam kawah kari itu. Video hiasan Formula ramuan itulah akhirnya menjadi makanan untuk disajikan kepada rakyat Malaysia yang berbilang kaum. Artikel ini cuba bertiwikrama 😂 merayaui seluruh alam politik Malaysia di mana pancaroba yang dilalui umpama penyakit cari sendiri. Nota: Bertiwikrama adalah istilah yang digunakan oleh Anwar Ibrahim pada 2 Oktober 2023 di Facebook k
Read more

Gaji CEO TNB khabarnya berjuta, tapi prestasi GLC itu macam tak sepadan

Image
Memalukan kerajaan negeri Johor, kata Menteri Besar Akhbar Harian Metro semalam melaporkan Menteri Besar Johor Datuk Onn Hafiz Ghazi menyifatkan insiden gangguan bekalan elektrik di Kompleks Kastam, Imigresen dan Kuarantin (CIQ) Bangunan Sultan Iskandar (BSI) Tambak Johor sebagai memalukan kerajaan negeri. Katanya, beliau telah mengarahkan pihak Tenaga Nasional Berhad (TNB) dan Jabatan Kerja Raya (JKR) diarahkan menyelesaikan isu terbabit. "Apa yang berlaku ini amat menyusahkan pengguna dan memalukan negeri. "Pihak TNB dan JKR telah diarahkan untuk menyelesaikan isu ini pada kadar segera," katanya dalam hantaran di media sosial. Terdahulu media melaporkan CIQ BSI di Tambak Johor di Johor Bahru mengalami gangguan bekalan elektrik lebih 12 jam dipercayai terjadi pada jam 8 malam tadi dan berlarutan hingga jam 10 pagi. Insiden itu menimbulkan keluhan dalam kalangan rakyat Malaysia yang bekerja di Singapura apabila terpaksa berbaris panjang dan lama kerana proses cap paspor
Read more

GEMPAR: MUFTI PERLIS TERLIBAT BUNUH AMRI CHE MAT?

Image
ADA UNSUR PREJUDIS DALAM TULISAN FAISAL TEHRANI, SECARA JELAS MERUJUK KEPADA MUFTI PERLIS, DR MAZA WALAUPUN TIDAK MENYEBUT NAMA Motif "menculik dengan niat membunuh" dan menggunakan anggota keselamatan negara atas bidang kuasa mufti didorong keyakinan serta ketaksuban fahaman Wahabi dan Salafi yang berpusat di Arab Saudi, dengan pemikiran hanya aliran fahaman mereka sahaja yang betul. Namun, pandangan Faisal Tehrani tidak boleh diabaikan begitu sahaja. Prof. Bersekutu Dr. Mohd Asri Zainul Abidin, secara komersial dikenali sebagai Dr. Maza,  pendakwah Salafi, penulis, pensyarah dan pemikir/perunding agama Islam dari Malaysia. Beliau kini memegang jawatan Mufti Perlis untuk kali kedua sejak 2 Februari, 2015. Tempoh pertama beliau sebagai mufti Perlis dari 2006 hingga 2008.   MISTERI kehilangan yang dipercayai diculik dengan niat untuk membunuh Amri Che Mat, Pastor Raymond Koh dan tiga lagi personalìti berkaitan agama Islam dan Kristian masih menunggu jawapan pasti.
Read more

Jabatan Penjara Malaysia jawab "Abang Mat" mengenai layanan kepada Anwar sebagai banduan

Image
Media tempatan melaporkan Jabatan Penjara Malaysia menegaskan dakwaan seorang individu mengenai layanan istimewa terhadap Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim ketika menjalani hukuman di Penjara Sungai Buloh adalah tidak benar serta berniat jahat. Menerusi kenyataan, jabatan itu berkata pihaknya telah meneliti wawancara individu berkenaan yang mengaku sebagai bekas banduan di penjara Sungai Buloh menerusi sebuah rakaman video di Youtube. TONTON VIDEO👇 Video dari YouTube bertarikh 3 Disember 2023. Menurut portal berita arus perdana Malaysiakini , individu itu, yang mmperkenalkan dirinya sebagai ‘Abang Mat’ antara lain mendakwa terdapat "blok VIP" di penjara untuk ahli politik, dan Anwar pernah memintanya untuk membersihkan bilik berkenaan. Menjawab perkara itu, jabatan penjara berkata, tiada bilik untuk menempatkan banduan VIP di Penjara Sungai Buloh dan mana-mana penjara lain seperti didakwa individu terbabit. "Anwar telah ditempatkan di klinik Penjara Sungai Buloh di atas pengesyo
Read more

Jika DAP dapat memberi kebaikan kepada orang Melayu, lebih baik dari pemimpin Melayu, apa masalahnya? Kalau...

Image
Tokoh kontroversi Tamrin Ghafar dipanggil polis untuk siasatan Malaysia telah menyaksikan pemimpin parti menang hanya 13 kerusi parlimen jadi PM, PM sekarang pun partinya menang kurang 30 kerusi PAS yang menang paling banyak kerusi di PRU15 hanya mampu jadi pembangkang Media melaporkan Datuk Mohd Tamrin Tun Abdul Ghafar ( dua gambar di atas ), anak bekas timbalan perdana menteri akan disoal siasat polis Selasa depan berhubung catatan di blognya yang meramalkan penguasaan DAP terhadap politik Malaysia pada masa hadapan. “Tamrin dijadual memberikan keterangannya kepada polis pada 16 April jam 10.30 pagi,” kata peguam Tamrin Encik Rafique Rashid Ali kepada   Free Malaysia Today , seperti dipetik portal berita dari media arus perdana, Malaysiakini . Allahyarham Tun Abdul Ghafar Baba Tamrin merupakan anak kepada Allahyarham Tun Abdul Ghafar Baba. Dalam catatan di blog Tamrin bertarikh 4 April, beliau berkata semua orang Melayu dan raja-raja Melayu mesti sedar bahawa malapetaka akan menimpa
Read more

Dr Rafidah sounds emotional, more like personal grudges

Image
Is there any official regulation a bankrupt cannot be a government servant? Are you killing them without utilising each individual's expertise in good faith? A news portal from the mainstream media reported nephrologist Dr Rafidah Abdullah has urged a public university to explain why it allowed a person who has been declared a  bankrupt   to lead one of the departments under its medical faculty. Rafidah said the vice-chancellor of the varsity must explain the matter, especially since the government’s regulations bar bankrupts from being hired for the public services. “Come on, university XX, please explain. Don’t embarrass the university,” FMT quoted Rafidah as saying in a Facebook post, keeping the varsity’s name anonymised. She added that she will file a complaint which would be more specific. A university spokesman later told the news portal that investigations were being carried out into the matter. An announcement would be made on Monday (tomorrow). Rafidah also claimed that
Read more